Pirates Fans Remain Loyal Despite Historic Collapse

After 20 consecutive losing seasons, Pirates fans continue to look to the future for their moment of glory.

Pirates blogger Jon Anderson was just a year old the last time his hometown team had a winning record.

Ryan Godsey's earliest Pirates memory is the 1992 season, when the roster showcased superstars Barry BondsJay Bell and Andy Van Slyke.

Chris Barron first experienced the Pirates in the 1979 World Series when the Baltimore Orioles lost to the Buccos—the last major pro sports team to win a Game 7 championship on the road until the Penguins defeated the Detriot Red Wings 30 years later.

"I was 5 years old, and I remember thinking the Orioles sounds like Oreos, which is a cookie, which sounds like a dumb name for a baseball team, so I'm going to root for the Pirates,” Barron reminisced, smiling.

The Pittsburgh Pirates' history continues 20 years of struggle and loss, capping off the 2012 season with modern sport's most epic collapse. Fans remain vigilant, knowing the Pirates will one day reward their steadfast loyalty and dedication.

On Aug. 6, the Pirates were statistically poised for their first postseason run in a generation. This Pirates team is officially the first Major League team ever to be 16 or more games over .500 108 games into the season and end with a losing record. How do fans continue knowing this is baseball's largest collapse ever?

Anderson, a 21-year-old senior at Waynesburg University, explains, "A lot of people are losing their minds over it, but I'm pretty good at realizing it's just a sport."

Anderson is able to keep his emotions away from the game, claiming that placing personal stock in sports yields misery.

Growing up part of a generation privy to baseball failure, Anderson recalls his classmates' ridicule and jokes because he supports the Pirates. In 2009, he started blogging, naming his blog The "Mc" Effect, a play on the many Pirates with "Mc" in their surnames (McDonald, McKenry, McPherson, two McCutchens). The persistent losing doesn't deter Anderson, though, from blogging and enjoying baseball.

"Nobody wants to support a loser, and nobody wants to be viewed as a loser," he said. "But just liking that team doesn't mean that you have anything to do with it (the losing).

"It's not my fault."

While Anderson patiently awaits his first chance to experience a Pirates postseason, he has enjoyed the ride this season and the excitement the Pirates created, filling PNC Park almost more than ever. However, he recognizes that, for others, patience is virtually nonexistent. Fans are coping by using nasty jokes and cynical remarks.

"It seemed like, at the very worst, they'd finish above .500," Anderson said, "and that would be something to be happy about. But then everything fell apart.

"It's just a sport, and it doesn't mean much at the end of the day."

Conversely, not all fans are levelheaded like Anderson.

Barron, who is 38, epitomizes the emotionally invested fan. In a Skype interview, Barron proudly wore a Pirates T-shirt, gesturing passionately as he spoke.

"I wish I could be apathetic," he said. "I wish I couldn't care. Life would be easier if I didn't care."

But Barron does care, and while he understands that the team's collapse isn't personal, he can't help but take it personally sometimes.

Pirates President Frank Coonelly has said that no front office changes would be made to the team for next year, which outraged Barron. He raised his voice, criticizing the organization.

"It was like someone kicked me in the gut. Even after a historic collapse, no changes are going to be made?"

It hasn't been all bad for Barron through these past two seasons.

He recounted the Pirates' 2011 home series against the Boston Red Sox.

"There were 40-percent Red Sox fans (at PNC Park). There was something even better about having that many Red Sox fans there and us winning those two games. It was like David and Goliath."

For Barron, baseball is a family sport and pastime. He bonds with his father and brother over baseball, and though he is not native to Pittsburgh—growing up in North Carolina—this is his team.

He knows deep down that Pittsburgh is truly a baseball town and that "people are so hungry to have a decent baseball team."

Godsey, 25, stands in the middle emotionally, steadily becoming more detached.

"I stick with my team, but I'm a realist,” he said matter-of-factly.

Late in the Pirates' season, Godsey watches the games but not with the same heart as he did earlier in the season. It is now more background noise, and the thrill is gone, especially now that they statistically chalked up a 20th losing season with a 1-0, no-hit loss to the Cincinnati Reds on Sept. 28, hammering the final nail into the coffin.

Godsey seemed slightly exasperated, yet apathetic, regarding the Pirates' demise.

"I'm just shut down by it all," he said. "It's laughable for me now. I'll put the game on on mute and do something and look over, and it's, 'Here we go again.'"

Like many fans, Godsey is used to the Pirates falling apart, and reality is a hard pill to swallow. But he doesn't abandon his team.

Godsey recalls the night of the infamous "Sid Bream Slide." However, he did not see it; his father sent him to bed before the game ended.

He does remember his father breaking a TV remote.

"That's the only time he's ever done something like that."

Loyalty is the common thread binding Anderson, Barron, Godsey and the Pirates.

They all agree there is nothing the Pirates can do that will force them to turn in their fan cards, but their level of expectation for the future is cautiously optimistic.

Anderson believes that the Pirates cannot lose forever, relying on "statistics and probability."

Barron's thoughts mirror Anderson's, stating that, "You think it's impossible: that the streak can't go on that much longer."

After following the team for 33 years, Barron is here for the long haul.

"I'm already planning my trip to spring training, and I'll fully have myself talked into 'This is the year.'"

Godsey's foresight tells him that next year has to be it for this team.

"If they don't win 88 or 90 games, everyone's head is gonna roll, including Frank Coonelly's."

Anderson looks forward to the days ahead when the Pirates are more than a joke's punch line.

"It wouldn't be 'The City of Champions and the Pirates,'" he said. "A few games over (.500) could change everything."

Win or lose, Wild Card or blockbuster collapse, Pittsburgh is a baseball town, and it just takes one winning season to make it click.

Anderson, while keeping himself at an arm's length from the team, understands the Pirates' importance to Pittsburgh.

"A winning season would have changed the whole perspective on the Pittsburgh Pirates."

The writer is a Baldwin Borough native and Baldwin High School graduate.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Scott Baret October 08, 2012 at 03:11 AM
Although I will always be a loyal Pirates fan no matter where I live or what the team's record is, I am still shaking my head after the team failed to upgrade the team the right way. In fact, nearly every move they made from July onward was a downgrade. 1. Brad Lincoln was easily the team's best reliever at the time of the trade. Instead of shipping him for Travis Snider (see below), why not hold on to him and use some other bargaining chip, perhaps one of the younger pitchers, to get an upgrade for the outfield? 2. It made little sense to trade for Snider since Jose Tabata is so similar and was actually sent down shortly before that trade was made. Alex Presley is basically Tabata/Sinder with extra speed. Why not get something we don't have a bunch of already? Also, if they're going to try some sort of project where they try to pump life into another team's failed prospect, why do it in the middle of a playoff run? It didn't work with Brandon Wood last year. 3. Why trade for Chad Quallis and release Juan Cruz, replacing him with Hisinori Takahashi? Sure, Cruz made a miscue in that extra inning game, but he hadn't been too bad. A bullpen with Cruz, Grilli, Hanrahan, Lincoln, and Doug Slaten (sent down in spite of success) would have looked good at the end of the season. 4. Releasing Erik Bedard wasn't the best idea. Then again, neither was letting Paul Maholm, who was better than Bedard, walk for nothing.
Scott Baret October 08, 2012 at 03:16 AM
5. The coaching seems to be a huge problem, especially in the instruction department. They knew James McDonald was falling apart. Why let him struggle and not fix something? The same goes for Bedard, who was fine in the first two months, and also for Jeff Karstens, who regressed this year. Why couldn't we figure out Nate McLouth earlier in the year--yet the Orioles were able to turn him around? How did Alex Presley manage to take a step backward? The baserunning and bunting blunders are also a disgrace. 6. In short, the team is making all the same mistakes they did in the past. They don't know who to hold on to (see also the 1997 Expansion Draft/Joe Randa and 2003 Rule 5 Draft/Jose Bautista and Chris Shelton), make bad trades (see also Jason Bay and Aramis Ramirez), lock up the wrong guys too quickly (see also Pat Meares), and sign over-the-hill free agents (see also Jeromy Burnitz). Huntington and Stark need to be replaced with experienced guys, not more Littlefields or Bonifays. Where is Sid Thrift when you need him?
Oren Spiegler October 08, 2012 at 09:53 AM
I love Pirates baseball win or lose, and enjoy the great PNC Park experience. I fear, though, that us Pirates fans must accept that the team seems to be doomed. Even if management were willing to pay to acquire great players, the losing mentality that has set in after twenty years is difficult to diminish, and makes it more impossible with each passing year that top-notch free agents would be willing to join the Pirates regardless of how much money thrown at them. We have seen this already; this year we attempted to acquire pitcher Edwin Jackson, offering him a generous multi-year contract; he chose to sign with the Nationals for a one-year deal. We sought to talk to pitcher Roy Oswalt with the intention of tendering an offer; he would not return the club's calls, now he is a member of the Texas Rangers, a team currently playing post-season baseball. I became a partial season ticket holder this year and will be next year as well. Hope springs eternal, but as a realist, I note that if the Pirates ever become end-of-season winners, it will be a delightful surprise. It will be more reasonable to expect that they shall be a perennial fourth place finisher.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »